The Madison Street Cemetery is made up of three distinct cemeteries shown on map (1) Congregational Church Cemetery, (2) Cobb Cemetery, and (3) Lewis Wickwire Vault Company that merged and came under the care of the Village of Madison. The Village of Madison purchased land (4) in 1899 to expand the cemetery to the west. Older stones in this cemetery are remains and gravestones removed from the Old Congregational Church and Baptist Society Burying Grounds. A notable buried in this cemetery is Emily Chubbuck Judson who wrote under the pen name of Fanny Forrester.