Sometime prior to 1893, after the German Methodist Church ceased operation, the building that originally stood on these grounds became the meeting place for the Lyceum. (many stones damaged) http://www.oysterbaytown.com/vertical/sites/{7D6BDBFB-65E8-4A80-B369-DE0267DC78CB}/uploads/{4BFD60D3-EA6E-44B9-8D5E-A9EA39208165}.PDF Methodist Church Cemetery AKA Lyceum Cemetery Located on the north side of the Hempstead Turnpike west of Stewart Avenue. Grave markings dated l8l8 to l995. Church ceased operations prior to 1893. Building then became a meeting place for the Lyceum. Alfred S. Walters first Farmingdale Civil War casualty (died 1865) buried here. Inscriptions DAR 1941 (Information from Historic Cemeteries of Oyster Bay)